St. Thomas Tommies at Valparaiso Beacons prediction: Title hopes meet Senior Day on Nov. 21, 2026
The Tommies are 77% favorites and the Beacons are at 25% in Saturday's Pioneer Football League finale. A Tommies run game that piled up 269 yards last week meets a Beacons pass rush with 27 sacks, and the quarterback job could change hands.
Football
By OG.com Staff

The Tommies visit the Beacons on Saturday, Nov. 21, in the Pioneer Football League finale at Brown Field. The Tommies (8-3, 5-2 PFL) can clinch a share of the conference title with a win, but only if Dayton and Butler both lose.
The Beacons (5-5, 4-3) are playing for a first of their own. A win on Senior Day would be their first ever against the Tommies, who lead the series 5-0, and would give coach Andy Waddle's team its first winning season since spring 2021.
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
When is Tommies vs Beacons?
- Date: Saturday, November 21, 2026
- Kickoff: 2 p.m. ET
- Competition: College football, Week 12
- Home team: Beacons
- Tommies win: 77%
- Beacons win: 25%
What is the Tommies vs Beacons prediction?
The Tommies are favorites at 77%, with the Beacons at 25%, according to market data as of 20 Nov 2026. For the latest probabilities, check OG.com. These percentages reflect the market's expectations, not guaranteed outcomes. Prediction market prices can change as traders react to new information.
The strongest case for the Tommies runs through the ground game. Joseph Koch ran for 233 yards and five touchdowns on 32 carries against Drake, and the Tommies have averaged 221 rushing yards over their last five games.
The Beacons gave up 255 rushing yards at San Diego and 226 against Presbyterian, but they held Drake to 59 and Dayton to 102. Max Samuel's 9.0 sacks and 20.5 tackles for loss give them a way to disrupt that run game before it builds momentum.
The Beacons' route to an upset needs short fields and turnovers. They won the turnover battle 6-1 against Drake while being outgained 323-250, and their game notes list six blocked punts and eight blocked kicks, both at or near the top of the FCS.
Overtime is a live possibility in a series of close finishes, since the Beacons beat Stetson 32-31 in overtime at Brown Field last November. Check the contract terms to see how overtime is handled.
Tommies vs Beacons win probabilities
- Tommies win: 77%
- Beacons win: 25%
How could Tommies vs Beacons unfold?
If the Tommies score early, the game can get away from the Beacons quickly. Against Drake they led 27-0 after one quarter, and Anthony Policare finished 12 of 20 for 283 yards, including an 80-yard touchdown to Quentin Cobb-Butler.
Road games have been the Tommies' soft spot. Both of their league losses came away from home, 55-21 at Presbyterian and 41-14 at Butler, and at Butler they lost three turnovers and ran for only 77 yards.
The Beacons can stay in range by controlling the clock. At Stetson, a team that is 1-10, Rowan Keefe threw a career-high 303 yards and Cedric Benning III ran for 98 on 18 carries. The Beacons held the ball for 35:57 and converted 7 of 16 third downs.
Special teams could swing the game as well. Chris Gundy has three punt return touchdowns, tied for the FCS lead, while the Tommies' coverage gave up a 93-yard kickoff return to Drake last week. A late Beacons lead would also test a Tommies defense that allowed 434 passing yards in that game.
What is the latest team news?
The Tommies carry three open injury questions from the Butler game, and ESPN lists no injury designations for the Beacons.
What is the latest on the Tommies?
Nick Peipert, who has 1,622 passing yards and 13 touchdowns this season, left the Butler game with an apparent injury at the start of the second quarter. Policare replaced him that day and ran the offense against Drake, and Peipert's status for Saturday has not been confirmed.
Running back Gabriel Abel, who has 635 rushing yards and nine touchdowns, was removed in the third quarter at Butler and was seen on crutches, according to The Crest. Linebacker Will Seymour, the team leader with 6.5 sacks, also left in the second half. Coach Glenn Caruso did not detail any injuries after the game.
What is the latest on the Beacons?
Keefe, the team captain, is the projected starter at quarterback according to the Beacons' game notes, and he has 2,000 passing yards and 13 touchdowns. Benning leads the rushers with 371 yards, Gundy leads the receivers with 489 yards, and Samuel anchors a defense with 27 team sacks.
What could decide Tommies vs Beacons?
Three matchups stand out: the Beacons' pass rush against a Tommies line that gave up three sacks at Butler, the Tommies' secondary against Keefe's passing, and the turnover battle.
Can the Beacons' pass rush disrupt the Tommies?
The PFL's weekly release lists the Tommies first in the conference in total offense at 444.3 yards per game. Butler sacked the Tommies' quarterbacks three times in the one league game where that line struggled, and Samuel and the Beacons' 70 tackles for loss give them the tools to try the same plan.
Can the Tommies' defense handle Keefe and the passing game?
Drake threw for 434 yards against the Tommies, but Preston Franklin intercepted two passes and Sam Shaughnessy added an interception and a fumble recovery. Keefe will look for Gundy, who caught eight passes for 122 yards at Stetson, and Marty O'Keeffe, who had six for 91.
Who wins the turnover battle?
The Tommies lost three turnovers at Butler and one against Drake while taking the ball away four times in that game. The Beacons forced six turnovers against Drake on Oct. 10, though Drake is 3-8 this season and the Beacons were outgained in that win.
How do common opponents compare?
Both teams have played Drake and Stetson. The Tommies beat Drake 55-35 and Stetson 64-21, and the Beacons beat Drake 21-13 and Stetson 34-31, though the games came on different dates and at different sites.
What does the Tommies vs Beacons head-to-head history show?
The Tommies lead the series 5-0 since joining the PFL in 2021. The Beacons lost 20-13 in 2021 and 16-10 in 2023, both on the road, and the other three meetings, including both at Brown Field, were blowouts, the latest a 55-17 Tommies win on Oct. 18, 2025.
Both rosters have changed since then, and the Beacons have already improved by three wins from last season. They have also won their last three Senior Day games, including that 32-31 overtime comeback from 24-0 down against Stetson.
What could move the Tommies vs Beacons market price?
Peipert's status is the clearest swing factor. He has rushed for 501 yards and 11 touchdowns this season, so his return or absence changes both the quarterback picture and the Tommies' run game, and Abel's status shapes the backfield around Koch.
The title race adds a second layer. Dayton at Presbyterian and Butler against Morehead State both kick off an hour before this game, according to the PFL, and their scores can change what the Tommies are playing for.
Injury news and early scores are common drivers of price changes in sports prediction markets. The rest of Saturday's schedule is in the daily sports prediction markets listing.
Important information
Important Information: Prediction is an event contract that is a derivatives product offered by North American Derivatives Exchange, Inc. (NADEX), a CFTC-regulated exchange, which does business under the brand OG.com Prediction Markets (OG) Crypto.com | Derivatives North America and uses a CFTC-regulated exchange that uses OG.com technology.
Trading on OG.com involves risk and may not be appropriate for all. By trading you risk losing your cost to enter any transaction, including fees. You should carefully consider whether trading on OG.com is appropriate for you in light of your investment experience and financial resources. Any trading decisions you make are solely your responsibility and at your own risk