Which Premier League team should you support? A guide for US fans 

But the World Cup is only one part of a sport that runs almost year-round, with domestic leagues, continental competitions and international tournaments offering plenty to follow between now and 2030.

This guide is for new soccer fans bitten by the World Cup bug who want to know where to get their next fix and where to direct their newfound passion – to the English Premier League.

Which Premier League clubs are most supported among US fans? 

According to UK Government data, these are the best supported Premier League teams among US fans.

1. Manchester United

England's most successful club and the record top-flight champions, though the Premier League title has eluded them since 2013. United remain a global giant living somewhat off past glories, chasing a return to the top after an underwhelming decade of rebuilding.

• League titles (First Division + Premier League): 20
• FA Cups: 13
• Champions League/European Cups: 3
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 1
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Bruno Fernandes, Portugal; Matheus Cunha, Brazil; Lisandro Martínez, Argentina

2. Liverpool

One of the two most successful English clubs, level with United on 20 league titles and Europe's most successful English side with six European Cups. Champions again in 2024-25 and firmly back among the elite at home and abroad.

• League titles (First Division + Premier League): 20
• FA Cups: 8
• Champions League/European Cups: 6
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 3
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Virgil van Dijk, Netherlands; Florian Wirtz, Germany; Alexander Isak, Sweden.

3. Tottenham Hotspur

A grand old name with two league titles from the mid-20th century and a strong cup pedigree, but long starved of major silverware until the 2025 Europa League win ended a 17-year trophy drought. A sleeping giant perennially trying to break back into the very top tier and always finding a way to mess it up.

• League titles (First Division): 2
• FA Cups: 8
• Champions League/European Cups: 0
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 3
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Cristian Romero, Argentina; Micky van de Ven, Netherlands; Pedro Porro, Spain.

4. Manchester City

The dominant force of the modern era, having transformed since their 2008 big money takeover into serial Premier League winners and 2023 European champions. The benchmark side of English football over the past decade, with an unmatched recent trophy haul, although often accused of buying success.

• League titles (First Division + Premier League): 10
• FA Cups: 8
• Champions League/European Cups: 1
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 0
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Erling Haaland, Norway; Rodri, Spain; Rúben Dias, Portugal

5. Chelsea

A mid-table club for much of their history who became a powerhouse after 2003, winning multiple Premier Leagues and two Champions Leagues. A modern heavyweight that has assembled one of the youngest, most expensive squads in world football.

• League titles (First Division + Premier League): 6
• FA Cups: 8
• Champions League/European Cups: 2
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 2
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Enzo Fernández, Argentina; Moisés Caicedo, Ecuador; Marc Cucurella, Spain

6. Newcastle United

A club with a proud early-20th-century history and, according to many fans, one of the most passionate fanbases in England. Most of its major honours came long ago, though there have been a few recent successes, including the 2025 League Cup. 

Now backed by significant wealth and steadily building toward a return to the top of the game. The upcoming season could be tricky for Newcastle though, having lost their manager and key players. 

• League titles (First Division): 4
• FA Cups: 6
• Champions League/European Cups: 0
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 0
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Bruno Guimarães, Brazil; Nick Woltemade, Germany; Dan Burn, England

7. Arsenal

One of England's traditional giants and record FA Cup winners, who ended a 22-year league title wait by winning the 2025-26 Premier League and reached the 2026 Champions League final. Back at the pinnacle of the English game after years of near-misses.

• League titles (First Division + Premier League): 14
• FA Cups: 14
• Champions League/European Cups: 0
• Europa League/UEFA Cups: 0
• Star players at World Cup 2026: Bukayo Saka, England; Declan Rice, England; William Saliba, France

How to choose a Premier League club 

Choosing a Premier League club is a big decision. In the UK, it’s very much frowned upon to switch allegiance once you’ve nailed your colors to the mast. The choice you make now can and should define your soccer fandom journey for the rest of your life.

In the UK, most people either support their local team or inherit a team from a parent. In many cases it’s both. As an American, you’ll need a strong justification for the team you pick.

Which Premier League clubs to follow if you support these US teams

According to a recent study by YouGov US, the most supported non-national US sports teams are:

• Seattle Seahawks
• Chicago Cubs
• Chicago Bulls
• San Francisco 49ers
• New York Yankees
• Pittsburgh Steelers
• Buffalo Bills
• Boston Celtics
• Chicago Bears

Based on historical success, underdog vs perennial champion narratives, idiosyncratic stars, and era-defining dynasties, here are the Premier League teams you should support if you already have a sworn allegiance to one of the world’s most popular American teams.

Seattle Seahawks → Newcastle United 

A deafening, cult-like home fortress (the 12s ↔ the Toon Army) with idiosyncratic cult heroes. Loud, brash, and riding a modern surge that's forced everyone to take them seriously again.

Chicago Cubs → Aston Villa

A grand old founder-era club with a glorious, distant peak (Villa were champions of Europe in '82) followed by decades of heartbreaking near-misses and loyal suffering. The lovable, faintly cursed institution whose faithful never stop believing and who've flickered back to life lately.

Chicago Bulls → Manchester City

The definitive dynasty of its era, a ruthless winning machine so dominant that rivals were effectively playing for second. Brilliant, relentless, and hated for making it look easy.

San Francisco 49ers → Arsenal

Elegant, aristocratic and built on playing the game beautifully, with a golden dynasty banked in the memory. Back among the elite after years of agonising near-misses.

New York Yankees → Manchester United

The richest, most glamorous and dominating force in the land: most titles, biggest global brand, and the club everyone else loved to hate. Serial winners who spend big and expect to win bigger.

Pittsburgh Steelers → Everton

Hard-nosed, blue-collar and soaked in tradition, a proud old-school club where toughness is the whole identity and the working-class fanbase never wavers. Never flashy, but sometimes overstating their own humility.

Buffalo Bills → Tottenham Hotspur

The eternal nearly-men, forever reaching the big one and inventing fresh ways to lose it, while their devoted fans struggle to keep the faith. Heartbreak as a lifestyle; it's the hope that kills you.

Boston Celtics → Liverpool

The dominant giants of their day and with a defining era-spanning rivalry (Celtics–Lakers ↔ Liverpool–United). Both teams are iconic, endlessly successful, and right back on top when it matters.

Chicago Bears → Leeds United

Big, storied and hard as nails. Each is a founding giant with a fearsome defensive reputation (Monsters of the Midway ↔ "Dirty Leeds") and one unforgettable era of dominance. Huge rabid fanbase, glorious past, and a long ache for the good days to come back.

Which Premier League clubs to follow if you loved these players 

According to a study by the Premier League, these are the World Cup 2026 fans favorites. If you fell in love with any of these stars at the tournament, these are the teams to follow.

Jordan Pickford (England/Everton)

Pickford became the most-capped England men’s player in World Cup history and underlined his importance with 19 saves, three of which came in a superb individual display against co-hosts Mexico in the round of 16.

Pedro Porro (Spain/Spurs)

Porro scored twice, with no defender netting more, and his second goal sealed Spain’s 2-0 semi-final win over France. He was a constant attacking threat, creating 10 chances and delivering the cross that led to the winning goal in the final against Argentina.

Cristian Romero (Argentina/Spurs)

Romero started all but one of Argentina’s matches as they reached a second successive World Cup final. His 79th-minute headed goal against Egypt sparked a 3-2 comeback win that sent Argentina into the quarter-finals.

Lisandro Martinez (Argentina/Man Utd)

Martinez stood out in the round of 32 against Cape Verde, assisting Lionel Messi’s opener before scoring himself in extra time. He also ranked seventh among all players for clearances (with 34) and ninth for accurate short passes (415).

Djed Spence (England/Spurs)

Spence was one of England’s breakout players, helping the Three Lions secure third place, their best World Cup finish since winning the competition in 1966. He impressed in both attack and defense, most memorably making an incredible recovery tackle to deny Giuliano Simeone a shot on goal in the semi-final.

Elliot Anderson (England/Man City)

Anderson started every England match apart from the third-place play-off and delivered all-action displays in midfield, especially during the knockout stages. Man City's summer signing ranked top in England's squad for tackles (with 21) and interceptions (eight, with Ezri Konsa) and third for passes.

Rodri (Spain/Man City)

Rodri led Spain to their second World Cup title and won the Golden Ball as the tournament’s best player. He set a tournament passing record, covered the most distance of any player and made the most tackles. Rodri misplaced only five of his 106 attempted passes in the final.

Enzo Fernandez (Argentina/Chelsea)

Fernandez was Argentina’s knockout-stage goalscoring hero, netting late against Egypt and England to help drive his side all the way to the World Cup final, where he became the villain after a reckless challenge saw him sent off for a second bookable offence.

Bukayo Saka (England/Arsenal)

Saka made a huge impact despite starting only three matches, finishing the tournament with three goals and three assists. His hat-trick against France was one of the standout individual displays of the competition.

Erling Haaland (Norway/Man City)

Haaland thrived in his first World Cup appearance, scoring seven goals in only five games. His two late strikes against Brazil in the round of 16 made him the first Norway player to score a knockout-stage brace at a major tournament.

Ismaila Sarr (Senegal/Crystal Palace)

Sarr enjoyed an excellent tournament, scoring four goals in four games and becoming Senegal’s all-time leading goalscorer at the World Cup.

FAQs about how to choose a Premier League team

How do I choose a Premier League team as an American? 

It could be your favorite player from the World Cup. If they weren’t a Premier League player, think about the sort of experience you want. If you’re looking for a quick shot at glory, go for one of the ‘Big 6’, if you want a more rewarding ride, pick based on history, location or fanbase.

Which are most supported in the US? 

Most supported Premiere League team sin the US are Manchester United, Liverpool, Tottenham Hotspur, Manchester City, Chelsea, Newcastle United, and Arsenal.

What factors should I consider? 

If you plan to visit England to watch a game, pick a smaller team where the chances of bagging a ticket are higher. Consider whether you’re OK with being called a “glory hunter” by other supporters. If that doesn’t matter, one of the big six teams could be fun. If the thought of it makes you cringe, pick a smaller but upwardly mobile team.

Do I need a geographic connection? 

It can certainly make things interesting; cities you’ve visited, ancestral connections or even a team that’s connected to your hometown somehow can all make the experience of following more rewarding.

Can I support one without knowing much about soccer yet?

Absolutely! The best way to learn about soccer is to have some skin in the game. Pick a team and enjoy the ride.